well, this is a difficult one to judge: both scenes are nearly the same... I'm gonna have to say 4/5 for accuracy. those figures are really good, the cooking pot is right, with the right ingredients, but smeagol is not wearing any pants XD . I wouldn't have done a SNOT surface, though, but I like it still XD pics are great, all are very clear: 5/5. I'm gonna say 4/5 for detail: love those plants! I had to go to the little details to judge this to find deifferences. total, 13/15 great total! you win by half a point! congrats! this was so close, I reckon you should have another round, or 2!