Attention to detail: 3/5 Some places look really good (the top of the back), but others are quite lacking, such as the lower front legs. Accordance with the set theme: 3.5/5 This totally looks like it would guard a coral reef. Without knowing the category though, I feel like a may be a bit lost as to what it's supposed to be. Some of the odd shapes I feel work with the theme, because of how varied coral can be.
Posability: 4/5 Everything appears to be quite poseable, except the neck. Colors: 3/5 I feel like the black is relied upon a bit to much in prominent places, and the brown looks out of place. Realism: 3/5 Without knowing the category, I probably wouldn't think of a coral reef immediately. That said, once known, I can picture it relatively well in it's environment. 16.5/25 Overall, nice work! Really like some of the ideas here.
Detail:3/5 Theme: 4/5 Posability: 3.5/5 Colors: 3/5 Realism: 3.5/5
You were very attentive with some of the details on the front half, but the back half doesn't look like it got as much attention. It does look like a guardian of a coral reef, so great job there! In the pictures, he does not look that posable, but I could be wrong about that. As for the colors, the brown really sticks out to me and I don't really think it should be there. As for realism, he looks menacing sort of like a dog. my total is 17/25.
Wow, looks great! My scores:
Attention to Detail: 3.5/5 He looks pretty cool, very much 01 Rahi-esque, which I don't see a lot of, I like it (plus, Skull Spiders I'm a sucker for!).
Accordance to Theme: 3/5 Very colorful, but perhaps a few more vibrant colors would be good (granted, tho, this is Bionicle).
Posability: 4/5 From what I can gather, he looks fairly poseable, but his neck appears to be one long CCBS bone, which is awkward.
Colors: 3/5 See aforementioned Accordance to Theme, also too much blue, but great usage of brown!
Realism: 2/5 This looks like a massive rock creature, which is what coral is like, but it looks too land-oriented and not very much like a water-dwelling creature as coral is.
Final Score: 15.5/25 (3/5)
Well done, man! Keep it up!
Looks super sweet! Way cool!
No one is getting outed this round but I might as well judge!
1. Attention to detail: 3/5
2. Accordance with the set theme; 4/5
3. Posability; 4/5
4. Colors; 4/5
5. Realism; 3/5
Now 5/5 would be like extra-above and beyond A++ stuff. 4/5 is still an A!